top of page
Search

Learning to Trust Yourself: Breaking Free from Shame and Religious Trauma

Writer: Kimberly Wilder
Kimberly Wilder
Oct 29
9 min read

Raised on Shame | Season 2: Deconstructing Happily Ever After


What happens when the people and institutions you trusted to teach you who you are also taught you not to trust yourself?


For many people raised in high-control religious environments, shame isn't simply an emotion that comes and goes. It becomes a framework for understanding the world, other people, and, perhaps most damagingly, ourselves.


We learn that obedience is virtuous, questioning is dangerous, pride is sinful, and our own instincts cannot be trusted. Over time, those messages can become so deeply embedded that we no longer recognize them as beliefs we were taught. We experience them as truths about who we are.


In this episode of Raised on Shame, I reconnect with my longtime friend and fellow therapist, Timothy Webster, to explore what happens when we begin questioning those truths and discovering who we might be without them.


Our conversation takes us from the religious environments of our childhoods to Argentina, Afghanistan, and Chile, exploring depression, military trauma, religious deconstruction, and the sometimes terrifying process of learning to trust ourselves.


The Person Everyone Sees Isn't Always the Person Who Is Suffering

Tim and I met in Argentina about 20 years ago, when we were both participating in a religiously affiliated study abroad program.


When I think back on that time, I remember Tim as one of the funniest, most easygoing people in our group. He was someone who made people laugh and seemed to approach life with a certain lightness.


What I didn't know was that he was experiencing significant depression.


During our conversation, Tim shared that depression had been such a consistent part of his life that he had come to understand it as normal. Even when he appeared happy and outgoing, he was struggling internally, sometimes with thoughts of not wanting to be alive.


It was a reminder of something I encounter frequently in my work as a therapist: We cannot determine someone's internal experience simply by observing how they present to the world.

Humor, kindness, competence, and sociability can coexist with profound psychological suffering.

For people raised in environments where difficult emotions are discouraged or interpreted as spiritual failures, recognizing and expressing that suffering can be especially complicated.

Sometimes we become so skilled at presenting the version of ourselves others expect that we lose touch with what we're actually experiencing.


When Shame Is Taught as a Virtue


Tim grew up in a fundamentalist Christian environment shaped by the teachings of Bill Gothard and the Advanced Training Institute of America.


His childhood was defined by rigid expectations surrounding clothing, music, behavior, and obedience. Even seemingly ordinary decisions were subject to religious rules and scrutiny.

As we talked, I recognized so many parallels with my own upbringing.


I remember growing up in a church where women were not permitted to wear pants and where the King James Version of the Bible was considered the only acceptable English translation. These weren't presented as preferences or interpretations. They were presented as moral absolutes.


For Tim, one of the most persistent messages was that he should never take pride in himself.

Not in his appearance. Not in his abilities. Not in his accomplishments.


The message was that feeling good about yourself was something to be suspicious of.

Consider what happens when a child internalizes that belief.


If pride is sinful, confidence becomes dangerous. If obedience is the highest virtue, autonomy becomes threatening. If questioning authority is wrong, learning to trust your own judgment can feel like a moral failure.


Eventually, shame no longer requires someone else to enforce it.

We learn to do that ourselves.


When Deconstructing Your Faith Feels Like Losing Your Entire World


One of the most meaningful parts of our conversation centered on the experience of religious deconstruction.


People often describe trauma or major life disruptions as having the rug pulled out from under them.


But for those of us raised in highly controlling religious environments, I think the experience can be more profound.


It's not simply that the rug disappears.


It's that the entire house disappears.


The beliefs that shaped your understanding of morality, relationships, identity, purpose, and the future suddenly become uncertain.


And when those beliefs have been woven into nearly every aspect of your life, questioning them can feel like losing the very structure that held your world together.


For me, that questioning began during our time in Argentina.


Being surrounded by Christians from different backgrounds exposed me to interpretations of scripture that contradicted what I had been taught was unquestionably true.


I remember realizing that people who were equally sincere in their faith held very different beliefs about which Bible translation was acceptable.


It might sound like a small realization, but for someone raised to believe there was only one correct answer, it was profound.


If something I had been taught with absolute certainty wasn't necessarily true, what else might I need to reconsider?


For Tim, the process unfolded differently.


His experiences in the military, his relationships, and eventually his decision to move to Chile all contributed to a gradual reevaluation of the beliefs and expectations he had inherited.


Neither of us describes deconstruction as a simple rejection of everything we once believed.

Instead, we talk about the difficult work of examining those beliefs individually and deciding which ones still align with our values.


That distinction matters.


Healing from religious trauma does not require abandoning spirituality or faith. It requires having the freedom to determine what those things mean to you.


Good Intentions Can Still Cause Harm


Another important theme in our conversation is the distinction between individual intentions and harmful systems.


When we reflect on the religious communities that shaped us, it can be tempting to divide people into categories of good and bad.


But human relationships are rarely that simple.


I remember people in our religious program who were genuinely kind, compassionate, and invested in helping others. I also remember practices that, looking back as a therapist, I recognize as inappropriate and harmful.


Both things can be true.


People can sincerely believe they are helping while participating in systems that undermine autonomy, reinforce shame, or cross personal boundaries.


Recognizing that complexity doesn't excuse harm.


It allows us to understand how harmful practices can persist even when the people participating in them believe they are doing the right thing.


And it creates space for a more nuanced understanding of our own histories.

We don't have to deny the positive experiences we had to acknowledge the damage that was done.


Why We Keep Choosing the Chair with Nails


One of the most striking moments in our conversation came when Tim described a metaphor he had recently used to explain his relationship with himself.


Imagine two chairs.


One is comfortable, with a soft cushion.


The other has nails sticking out of it.


Tim explained that, for much of his life, he would have chosen the chair with nails.

Not because it was comfortable.


Because he believed he deserved it.


That image captures something essential about shame.


When we internalize the belief that we are fundamentally flawed, undeserving, or sinful, suffering can begin to feel appropriate.


We may become relentlessly critical of ourselves, dismiss our accomplishments, struggle to accept kindness, or feel uncomfortable when life is going well.


And often, we don't even recognize how harshly we're treating ourselves.


As a therapist, I frequently encounter people who speak to themselves in ways they would never speak to someone they love.


They extend compassion to friends, family members, and even strangers while withholding that same compassion from themselves.


For those raised with persistent messages about their inherent sinfulness or unworthiness, this pattern can be especially difficult to recognize and change.


The critical voice feels familiar.


Sometimes it even feels righteous.


But being cruel to ourselves is not the same as being accountable, humble, or good.

Learning to distinguish between those things is an important part of healing.


Learning to Feel Again


When I asked Tim what he was most grateful for in this new chapter of his life, his answer was surprisingly simple.


He was grateful to be able to feel.


For much of his life, Tim described experiencing profound emotional and even physical numbness. He had become so disconnected from his own sensations that he believed it was normal.


Now, as he continues his healing journey, he's beginning to experience sensations that once felt inaccessible to him.


He talked about noticing colors, feeling his skin, and becoming more aware of his emotions.

These experiences are beautiful, but they can also be overwhelming.


During our conversation, I explained how dissociation can function as a protective response to trauma.


When our environments are emotionally unsafe, our nervous systems may adapt by reducing our awareness of feelings, sensations, or experiences that would otherwise be overwhelming.

That adaptation isn't evidence of weakness.


It's evidence of a system trying to survive.


And when safety begins to return, reconnecting with those experiences can be both exciting and frightening.


One of the things I emphasize in my clinical work is that healing isn't necessarily about eliminating the parts of ourselves that helped us survive.


It's about developing enough safety and flexibility that those protective responses no longer have to run our lives.


For Tim, part of that process has involved recognizing that he is allowed to feel, that his emotions aren't inherently dangerous, and that he doesn't need someone else's permission to experience his own life.


Sometimes Healing Begins with Doing Something Terrifying


Before moving to Chile, Tim described struggling with fear so intense that even ordinary activities, like going to the grocery store, felt overwhelming.


His experiences in Afghanistan and earlier childhood trauma had contributed to significant PTSD symptoms.


Moving to another country wasn't a simple solution to those experiences. But for Tim, making that decision became an important turning point.


He began establishing boundaries, exploring relationships in which he felt genuinely seen, and reconsidering the assumptions he had carried about himself for decades.


What struck me about his story was the relationship between fear and freedom.


Sometimes the very experiences that help us reclaim our autonomy require us to act before we feel completely ready.


That doesn't mean ignoring our nervous systems or pushing ourselves beyond what is safe.

It means recognizing that fear doesn't always have to make our decisions for us.


For someone who spent much of his life being told what to believe, how to behave, and even what he was allowed to feel, choosing his own direction was significant.


Redefining Happily Ever After


This season of Raised on Shame is about deconstructing happily ever after.

I wanted to explore not only religious deconstruction, but also the broader process of questioning the expectations we've inherited about relationships, success, identity, and what a meaningful life is supposed to look like.


Toward the end of our conversation, I asked Tim what happily ever after means to him now.

His answer wasn't about marriage, professional achievement, or reaching some grand destination.


It was about being able to go to a restaurant alone, sit at a table, and enjoy a meal.

There's something deeply meaningful about that.


For someone who has spent years struggling with fear, shame, and disconnection from himself, being comfortable in his own company represents a kind of freedom that no external accomplishment could provide.


And perhaps that's something worth reconsidering in our own lives.

What if happily ever after isn't a particular relationship, career, family structure, or set of accomplishments?


What if it's the ability to feel at home in our own lives?


Learning to Trust Yourself


Near the end of our conversation, I asked Tim what message he most wanted listeners to take away.


His answer was:


"Learn to trust yourself and your gut."


He encouraged listeners to quiet the constant noise of other people's opinions and expectations and begin paying attention to their own minds, bodies, and experiences.


For people raised in high-control environments, that can be extraordinarily difficult.

When you've spent years being taught that your instincts are unreliable, your feelings are dangerous, and your judgment must be subordinate to someone else's authority, trusting yourself can feel almost impossible.


But self-trust is something we can begin rebuilding.


We can learn to recognize our needs without immediately dismissing them. We can practice making decisions without seeking universal approval. We can acknowledge our mistakes without turning them into evidence that we're fundamentally flawed.


And we can begin separating the voices we've internalized from the values we actually want to live by.


That process isn't always linear.


Sometimes it involves grief for the childhood we didn't have, the relationships that changed, or the futures we once imagined.


Sometimes it involves anger at the people and institutions that shaped us.


And sometimes it involves the simple, unexpected joy of noticing the colors around us or sitting alone in a restaurant without feeling afraid.


Perhaps the most radical thing we can do after a lifetime of being taught to distrust ourselves is to believe that our own experiences, needs, and voices matter.


We don't have to have everything figured out.


We don't have to know exactly what we believe or where our lives are going.


We can give ourselves permission to question, explore, change, and grow.


And maybe, somewhere along the way, we discover that the person we were taught to distrust is someone we can finally learn to love.


Listen to the Episode


In Learning to Trust Yourself: Breaking Free from Shame and Religious Trauma, Timothy Webster and I explore the lasting impact of religious conditioning, the complexities of trauma and dissociation, and the freedom that comes from reclaiming our own identities.

Listen to the latest episode of Raised on Shame wherever you get your podcasts.

Content note: This episode includes discussions of religious trauma, depression, suicidal thoughts, PTSD, and military trauma.


 
 
 

Comments


If you have interacted with Wilder Wellness through workshops, educational programs, or community resources, you are welcome to leave a review.

© 2022 by Kimberly Wilder, LMHC and secured by Wix

bottom of page